DSE 英文

【DSE 英文】2024 DSE English Paper 2 Part B Q4 詳細題解

hero-image
blog-photo
學博小編16 Jun 2025

上幾篇文章分析了2024 DSE Paper 2首三條作文題目,相信同學對試卷的新結構和題型已經有初步的了解。在本部分,LearnSmart將繼續深入剖析餘下的作文題目,探討其設題方向、寫作難點及應試策略,並附上高分範文以供參考。希望同學能透過這篇文章掌握更多實用技巧,全面提升寫作能力,為應對新制Paper 2打下更穩固的基礎! 以下為2024 DSE English Paper 2 Part B Question 4 的詳細題解,由題目內容到考評局評分準則都為你一一拆解!

2024 DSE English Paper 2 Part B

Question 4

Hong Kong now has many more areas such as parks, shops and restaurants that welcome dogs. Some people feel that the city has gone too far in its efforts to be dog-friendly.

The Hong Kong Times is asking readers for their opinion. Write a letter to the editor expressing whether or not you support this new trend.



題目分析:

1. 背景

寫作者需撰寫一封信給當地報紙《Hong Kong Times》的編輯,表達對香港越來越多地區(如公園、商店、餐廳)歡迎狗隻這一現象的看法。



題目提供的關鍵背景細節:

  • 需要討論是否應鼓勵這一趨勢。

  • 寫信者可以選擇支持或反對,並需要清楚闡述自己的立場。

  • 支持的理由可能包括:狗主人希望帶寵物外出、支持犬隻陪伴需求(如情感支持動物)、犬隻需要運動與社交、以及對商業的正面影響(吸引更多顧客)。

  • 反對的理由可能包括:衛生問題、安全隱患、以及部分人不喜歡接近狗隻等。

  • 信件需反映寫作者的觀點,並通過邏輯推理和例子支持其論點。



2. 情緒

情緒應根據寫作者的立場進行調整,並以清晰且說服力強的語氣表達觀點。

支持性的情緒

  • 積極且具倡導性,強調狗隻作為家庭成員的重要性和狗友好場所的益處。
    eg. Allowing dogs in public spaces creates a more inclusive and compassionate city for all residents.

  • 鼓勵共鳴,突出狗主人與寵物之間的特殊聯繫。
    eg. As a dog owner, I know how important it is to spend quality time with my pet in spaces where they are welcome.



反對性的情緒

  • 理性且關注社會公共利益,強調不適合狗隻進入公共空間的潛在問題。
    eg. While I understand the love people have for their pets, hygiene and safety concerns must also be considered.

  • 表達對某些人群(如怕狗或過敏人士)的理解與支持。
    eg. Not everyone feels comfortable around dogs, and their preferences should also be respected in public spaces.



3. 目的 


淺層目的

  • 明確表達支持或反對狗隻友好場所的立場。
    eg. I believe Hong Kong should continue encouraging dog-friendly areas to foster a more pet-inclusive environment.

    eg. While I appreciate the bond between owners and their dogs, I believe this trend may be going too far and needs to be reconsidered.

  • 提供符合邏輯的理由並以實例支持觀點。



深層目的


支持

  • 倡導更多公共空間對狗隻開放,讓狗主人與寵物享受更多陪伴時間,並促進城市生活質量提升。
    eg. Including dogs in our public spaces strengthens the bond between owners and pets and promotes a healthier lifestyle for both.


反對

  • 呼籲平衡狗主人與其他市民的需求,防止過於極端的狗友好措施影響公共空間的舒適度和安全性。
    eg. We must ensure that public spaces are safe and enjoyable for everyone, including non-dog owners.



4. 對象

信件的目標對象是《Hong Kong Times》的編輯和報紙讀者,他們是社會公眾的一部分,可能包括支持或反對狗友好政策的人群。


如何有效地與目標對象交流

  • 使用正式且說服力強的語氣:信件應條理清晰、語氣得體,以便在公共領域引發討論。
    eg. Dear Editor, I am writing to express my views on the recent trend of increasing dog-friendly spaces in Hong Kong.

  • 清楚闡述立場並提供支持性論據:
    eg. With more people owning dogs in Hong Kong, it is only natural to adapt public spaces to accommodate this growing population.

    eg. While I understand the intentions behind creating dog-friendly spaces, we must also consider the potential challenges such as hygiene and safety.

  • 結尾包含明確的呼籲:
    eg. I urge local authorities to continue expanding dog-friendly areas while ensuring that rules are in place to maintain cleanliness and safety for all.

    eg. I hope the government and businesses can strike a balance by designating specific areas for dogs while keeping other spaces dog-free for those who prefer it.


考評局評分準則

1. 內容 (Content)

要求

從支持或反對的角度撰寫,表達對香港越來越多狗友好公共空間的看法,並提供相關論據。

表現特點

大多數考生能理解題目要求,清楚表達立場並提供支持的理由。

支持的觀點
狗主人希望帶狗隻同行、輔助犬的重要性、狗隻需要運動和陪伴、商家受益(如吸引更多顧客)。

反對的觀點
衛生問題、安全隱患、部分人對狗隻的不適感。

  • 優秀表現:論據多樣化且創新,能提出具體且相關的例子來支撐觀點,例如參考國際案例或提供詳細情境。

  • 較弱表現:觀點模糊,缺乏明確的支持或反對立場,或者論據不充分、不相關。



2. 語言 (Language)

要求:採用正式且說服力強的語調,適合公開信的形式。

表現特點:

  • 使用與主題相關的詞彙,如衛生、安全、寵物友好空間等,清楚闡述觀點。

  • 優秀表現:語言清晰流暢,能用有說服力的語句展開論點,並使用適當的語氣(如理性、客觀或熱情)。

  • 較弱表現:語言單調或過於正式,未能有效吸引讀者,或者語句結構不清晰,缺乏說服力。



3. 結構 (Organization)

要求:文章需符合公開信的格式,結構清晰有條理。

優秀表現:文章分段合理,包含:

  • 開頭:清楚說明主題和寫信目的(如表達對狗友好政策的看法)。

  • 主體:分段詳細闡述支持或反對的理由,並提供具體例子或邏輯推理支撐。

  • 結尾:提出明確的呼籲(如建議如何改善現狀或採取具體行動)。

較弱表現:結構不清晰,段落缺乏邏輯銜接,結尾模糊或無行動建議,導致文章說服力下降。




2024 DSE English Paper 2 Part B Question 4 範文

Dear Editor,

I am writing in response to the ongoing discussions about Hong Kong’s growing efforts to become a more dog-friendly city. The rise in parks, shops, and restaurants welcoming dogs has sparked mixed reactions, but as a passionate dog owner, I fully support this movement. It not only benefits people like me but also promotes responsible pet ownership and fosters stronger community connections.

Owning a dog in a bustling city like Hong Kong has always been challenging, especially with limited pet-friendly spaces. The expansion of such areas has greatly improved the lives of pet owners, providing much-needed opportunities to bond with our furry companions outdoors. Take the West Kowloon Cultural District, for example—its spacious lawns and waterfront trails have become a haven for dog owners, offering a safe and welcoming environment for pets to run and play. It’s refreshing to have spaces where we can relax with our pets without worrying about restrictions. Beyond recreation, spending time with dogs has been proven to reduce stress and improve mental health. In a fast-paced city like Hong Kong, dog-friendly areas provide an essential outlet for relaxation, creating a happier, healthier atmosphere for both pets and their owners.

These initiatives also play an important role in encouraging responsible pet ownership. Dog-friendly spaces inspire owners to train their pets to behave appropriately in public settings. For instance, The Barkyard in Sai Ying Pun is more than just a dog-friendly café—it’s a hub for community building, offering workshops on dog training and etiquette. These programs help owners better understand their pets’ needs and behaviours, fostering accountability and promoting harmonious interactions in shared spaces. Many parks, such as Quarry Bay Promenade, have also implemented sensible rules, requiring dogs to be vaccinated and leashed. These guidelines ensure pets are healthy and well-behaved while reducing risks like disease transmission or aggressive behaviour. By adhering to these measures, dog owners contribute to safer, more enjoyable public spaces for everyone.

Moreover, the rise of dog-friendly spaces has brought people closer together, creating opportunities for social connections. Parks like Cyberport Waterfront Park have become gathering spots where dog owners can bond over shared experiences. Families with children also benefit, as kids learn to interact safely and respectfully with dogs. Events hosted by dog-friendly businesses, such as the annual Pet Carnival at Stanley Plaza, not only support local enterprises but also nurture a sense of community. In a city as fast-paced and isolating as Hong Kong, these shared experiences are invaluable for building a more connected and compassionate society.

Critics have raised legitimate concerns about cleanliness and comfort in public spaces, particularly regarding dogs in restaurants or uncleaned messes in parks. However, I believe these issues can be addressed with proper regulations and enforcement. Many dog-friendly establishments, such as Little Creatures in Kennedy Town, have implemented rules to maintain a balance between accommodating pets and ensuring hygiene. Measures like leash requirements, designated seating areas, waste disposal stations, and clear signage—such as those found in the Central and Western District Promenade—help keep spaces clean and comfortable for everyone. These examples demonstrate that dog-friendly initiatives can coexist with public cleanliness and order.

In summary, Hong Kong’s efforts to become more dog-friendly are a positive step forward. They enrich the lives of dog owners, promote responsible pet care, and foster a greater sense of community. While concerns about over-accommodation exist, they can be managed through thoughtful regulations and education. As a proud dog owner, I’ve personally experienced how these initiatives enhance life for both pets and people. I hope Hong Kong continues to embrace this movement, setting an inspiring example for other cities to follow.

Yours sincerely,
Chris Wong


如果大家有補習問題,如私人補習、線上補習,歡迎Follow 「學博教育中心 Learn Smart Education」 Facebook page & IG得到更多補習課程資訊,亦都可以上我們的補習網頁了解更多!

為您推薦以下文章
Loading footer...